The Singapore Table Tennis Association (STTA) has changed its selection process* for the 2013 Asian Youth Games (AYG) and 2014 Youth Olympic Games (YOG) following pushy parents’ and the Singapore National Olympic Council (SNOC)’s objections. The latter had queried the STTA on its nomination process, pointing out, according to ST, that there were other players who were ranked higher than the nominees in the International Table Tennis Federation’s under-18 rankings.
But, as I see it, STTA is still fixing the selection process to get what it wants: preference for its Sports School proteges. Five out of the nine places on the training squad for thesegames are reserved for students from this school. Twenty main stream students have to fight for the remaining four places.
Yet STTA President Lee Bee Wah had the brazen balls to say: “I want to show that the STTA is prepared to be open and transparent about the selection process, and will do so based on merit and have the best represent Singapore.”
“On merit”? Sounds like the M’sian way to me. Give favoured people special privileges. This is not meritocracy.
She went on: “At the same time, we want to emphasise the long-term investment in the Sports School and SWS as the preferred developmental pathway for locals who want to commit themselves and excel in the sport.” So its all about protecting STTA’s patronage interests, is it? Typical M’sian, PRC attitude.
She does on. “While it is true that this doesn’t guarantee success, those who choose the sports school have a better chance of success with an environment that is conducive for training and overseas tournaments.
‘We recognise that there are talented athletes in mainstream schools, and we also will help them pursue their aspirations. But there are practical constraints in that the curriculum of a mainstream school may not accommodate a rigorous training schedule for top-flight competition.” Today
If STTA thinks that its rigorous training schedule is so impt to success, prove it: let those in the Sports School who can follow it compete with those who can’t. If STTA is right, gd for it. If not, back to the drawing board, albeit with loss of face. Let the results speak for themselves.
Seems STTA is afraid its “favoured’ players will lose, despite all the intensive training.
One can only hope the SNOC refuses to accept this farce of a selection process.
For those who oppose the PAP, the good thing, is that it shows the lie to the PAP claim that it believes in meritocracy., and that S’pore is a meritocracy. Here is a PAP FT MP who gives two fingers to “have the best represent Singapore.”
*[T]he STTA said it has revised its selection process for both events. For the YOG, nine places in the squad will be open to six boys and three girls aged 13 to 17, but they must commit to a 30-hour weekly training regimen that includes sparring sessions with the national team twice a week, or a 20-and-a-half-hour programme.
Those who choose the shorter programme must commit for three years but will not be able to train with the national players due to scheduling conflicts.
While five spots will be reserved for SWS students, 20 national youth team paddlers will be invited for trials to fill the remaining four places (two boys, two girls). Today
These nine will then compete in a round-robin contest to determine the best boy and girl to represent Singapore at the AYG.