SMRT: CEO stupidity discount?

In Infrastructure on 08/11/2011 at 6:00 am

Wonder if analysts will be building into their models, the assumption that SMRT chief executive Saw Phaik Hwa will continue making stupid remarks that upset commuters, thereby making it harder for SMRT (and Delgro) to get their desired fare rises? Will they also make the assumption that such gaffes reflect her inability to manage a public transport company?

In a recent ST report, the SMRT CEO commented that the MRT system is “still reliable compared with other systems” and “I don’t see anything significant” in the number of disruptions and delays.

She attributed the train breakdowns to higher service frequency, new trains that “need to break in”, and more rainy days in Singapore. She cites the newly installed platform screen doors at surface stations, which need to synchronise with train doors, as another factor in train disruptions.

Maybe by M’sian Chinese standards (she refuses to become a citizen, preferring to be a PR), comparisons with third world cities and even NY, London and Tokyo are in order. But she should not forget that she is the CEO of a transport company in a city that has aspirations to be a leading edge global city. If our ministers can set the global bench-mark paywise, SIA for premier service or or our local banks for solid balance sheets,  why can’t she set the global city benchmark disruption-wise when it comes to MRT systems?

Her other verbal gaffes: The SMRT chief had annoyed commuters last year when

— the issue of overcrowding was raised, “People can board the train, it is whether they choose to”; and

— she told commuters that they had a role in ensuring that trains were properly secured when there was a break-in at a train depot. She want us to volunteer to guard her train carriages.

  1. No worries, as long as her good friend The Jinx is in power, things will be fine for SMRT. Although valuation a bit high, but still ok lah. Rising dividends will still be declared, profits will still be chalked up. Sinkies will be thrown under the MRT before they will let SMRT report a net loss.

  2. […] board the train, it is whether they choose to” – SMRT CEO – Thoughts of a Cynical Investor: SMRT: CEO stupdity discount? – ST: Long wait for buses and trains unacceptable – InSing: SMRT continues to raise netizens’ […]

  3. She got the job because she is “someone”‘s school mate right?

  4. I have an interesting proposal to get the issues with our “public” transport into the heads of these senior management people.

    The government should mandate that ALL SMRT and SBSTransit senior management staff are required to travel to work everyday by the very public system that they so strongly defend? And to make things more interesting, their offices should only be situated in centralised locations like Raffles Place or Tanjong Pagar, and their working hours must coincide with the rest of us.

    Let them have a taste of their own medicine. It is their product, they should know exactly what they are selling.

  5. Wow!! Interesting comments!!! But I do agree on something though…..our transport fares are rising & we are getting more good “service” (i.e train breakdowns). What a embrassment especially that the breakdowns happened at the tourist belt of Orchard!! I wonder what Najib would say to PM LSH when they meet next month…Perhaps “now don’t embrass me with your transport system?”

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: